Last week I watched my wife spend forty minutes arguing with ChatGPT about whether our anniversary trip should include a “romantic sunset helicopter tour over an active volcano in Greece.” Spoiler alert: There are no active volcanoes in Greece. The AI was very confident though, I’ll give it that. After she finally gave up and pulled out her actual travel industry resources, the whole thing got sorted in about ten minutes, complete with a real sunset sailing experience in Santorini that didn’t involve imaginary lava flows.
This got me thinking about AI travel planning and how everyone’s jumping on the artificial intelligence bandwagon like it’s the next miracle solution. Don’t get me wrong – I use AI tools daily for work stuff, and they’re brilliant for certain tasks. But as travel advisors who’ve been in this business for years, watching people try to plan their dream vacations with AI is like watching someone use a hammer to fix their computer. Wrong tool for the job.
When AI Travel Planning Actually Works
Here’s the thing about using AI for travel: it’s not completely useless. I’ll be straight with you on this.
AI can give you a solid starting point for destination research. You can ask it about weather patterns, general costs, or what documents you need for entry. It’ll spit out basic information faster than you can crack open a cold one at your favorite brewery. That part’s genuinely helpful.
My better half and I used it recently to get a quick overview of visa requirements for our future Ecuador move. Saved us a Google deep-dive, got the basics in seconds. For straightforward factual questions, AI travel planning tools do just fine.
They’re also decent for suggesting general activities. “What do people usually do in Puerto Morelos?” will get you a reasonable list. You’ll see beaches, snorkeling, cenotes – all the standard stuff that’s probably already on your radar anyway.
Where AI Travel Planning Falls Apart Spectacularly
Now let me tell you where this whole AI travel planning thing becomes a dumpster fire wrapped in algorithms. And trust me, as someone who fixes these messes professionally, I’ve seen it all.
It makes stuff up. And I mean confidently, convincingly makes stuff up. Last month a client came to us after spending hours with an AI chatbot that recommended three family-friendly resorts in Jamaica. Sounded amazing on paper. One problem: two of them didn’t exist. The third had closed five years ago. But the AI described them in vivid detail, complete with pricing and amenities. Recent studies show that 90% of AI-generated travel itineraries contain at least one significant error, from recommending permanently closed attractions to suggesting you visit places outside their operating hours.
It has zero current information. Most AI models are trained on old data. They don’t know that restaurant closed last month, or that the hotel just got bought out and turned into a shopping mall, or that there’s currently a massive construction project blocking the beach access. Your dream vacation could be built on outdated information, and you won’t discover it until you show up. We spend hours every week staying current on these changes – it’s literally our job. AI? It’s working with yesterday’s news.
It can’t handle nuance. AI travel planning treats everyone like they’re the same cardboard cutout tourist. Tell it you want a romantic getaway, and you’ll get the same generic suggestions as the last thousand people who asked. It doesn’t understand that my idea of romance involves craft breweries and street food, while the missus prefers sunset sailing and boutique hotels. We need both, and AI just… doesn’t get it. There’s also the issue of hidden commercial bias – AI often recommends hotels that have aggressive marketing campaigns rather than the best value for your needs.
Customer service doesn’t exist. When something goes wrong – and trust me, something always goes wrong when you travel – you can’t call AI at 2 AM from a foreign airport. You can’t explain that yes, you know the website says the tour runs daily, but you’re standing at the meeting point and nobody’s here. That’s when people who’ve booked through us call us in a panic, and we fix it. AI leaves you stranded.
The Hidden Costs Nobody Mentions
Here’s what really gets me about AI travel planning. People think they’re saving money by doing everything themselves with artificial intelligence assistance. Sounds smart, right?
Wrong.
When you book everything separately through various websites that AI suggests, you’re missing out on package deals and industry connections that professionals like us have built over years. You’re paying retail prices for flights, hotels, and activities that we could bundle together for less. Plus, you’re spending your own time – hours of it – cross-referencing information and second-guessing AI recommendations.
That anniversary trip my wife tried planning with AI? The helicopter-over-fake-volcano situation wasn’t the only issue. The AI suggested hotels that cost 30% more than comparable properties we know and work with regularly. It recommended activities that were closed for renovation. And it had us flying through three connections when a direct route existed for basically the same price.
Why Professional Advisors Beat Any Algorithm
This is where I need to get real with you about something. Using AI for basic destination research? Sure, knock yourself out. But trying to plan an entire vacation with it? You’re setting yourself up for disappointment.
Professional travel advisors bring something to the table that no algorithm can match: we actually give a damn about your vacation. It’s not just our job – it’s our reputation on the line every single time.
When Tina and I explored the Bahamas, we knew exactly which islands would work for different client types before they even finished describing what they wanted. We understand that some people aren’t resort-all-day types. We get that some folks need local brewery access (guilty) while others need beach time, (right Tina?). AI would just list the top ten TripAdvisor beaches and call it a day.
Travel advisors have current, ground-truth information because it’s literally our job to stay on top of industry developments. We have relationships with properties and tour operators. When something goes wrong, we fix it. We’re working for you, not feeding you whatever statistical probability suggests most people might enjoy.
When the wife handled most of our client bookings at Boarding Pass Travel, and she pulled more bacon out of the fire than I can count. Flight cancellations, hotel overbookings, last-minute itinerary changes – she handled it. You know what AI does when your flight gets cancelled? Nothing. Absolutely nothing. You’re stuck refreshing airline websites at 3 AM while your vacation implodes.
The Smart Approach to Modern Travel Planning
Look, I’m not some Luddite screaming that all technology is bad. That would be ridiculous, especially coming from a guy who writes a travel blog and uses plenty of tech tools daily for our business.
The smart play is combining AI’s quick information retrieval with human expertise. Use AI to gather basic intel about destinations you’re considering. Get a sense of costs, weather, general activities. Think of it as your preliminary research assistant.
Then take that information to a qualified travel advisor who can separate the AI hallucinations from reality. They’ll tell you which suggestions make sense and which ones are completely bonkers. They’ll improve on the ideas, find better deals, and most importantly, they’ll be there when things inevitably go sideways.
When we help clients plan solo adventures, understanding both the practical logistics and the personal goals makes all the difference. AI could tell someone that Tokyo is safe for solo travelers, but we explain the cultural nuances and recommend specific neighborhoods that match their interests. That’s the difference between information and actual advice.
Finding an Advisor Who Gets It
Not all travel advisors are created equal, same as not all AI tools are equally useless. You need someone who actually listens to what you want instead of just pushing whatever commission earns them the most.
Good advisors ask questions. Lots of them. They want to understand your travel style, your budget, your must-haves and deal-breakers. They’re not trying to fit you into a pre-packaged formula.
They should have specialized knowledge. Someone who books Caribbean cruises all day might be brilliant at that, but they’re probably not your best bet for planning a European backpacking adventure. Find someone whose expertise matches your destination.
And here’s the big one: they should be honest with you. When the boss and I were considering an overpriced resort option in Riviera Maya for clients, we talked them out of wasting money and found better value elsewhere. That’s the kind of advocacy AI will never provide because it has no stake in whether you have a good trip or a terrible one.
The Bottom Line on AI Travel Planning
AI isn’t going away, and honestly, it shouldn’t. It’s got legitimate uses for gathering information quickly. But treating it like a replacement for professional travel planning is like asking your GPS to be your therapist. Wrong tool for the job.
Your vacation time is precious. You’ve earned it, you’ve saved for it, and you deserve better than a trip planned by an algorithm that might be making up half its suggestions. Use AI for the basics, sure. But when it comes to actually booking and planning something you’ll remember for years – or in our case, something you’ll bore people with stories about over craft beers at places like Cuenca’s Hop Scotch Pub – bring in a human who actually cares whether you have a great time.
Next time my better half suggests using AI to plan our anniversary trip, I’m shutting it down before she can finish the sentence. I’ve learned my lesson about imaginary Greek volcanoes. And after spending years helping clients recover from their own AI planning disasters, I’m not about to become one of our own cautionary tales.
Cheers! and better planning decisions,
The Beery Traveler
Leave a reply